Innovative educators are often asked for letters of recommendation from students as well as colleagues. This can become a little overwhelming if you don't have a few good strategies. Lisa Buitekant, Kris Karlson, Steve Warre, three teachers at Horace Greenley High School in Chappaqua, NY have a useful strategy that others can customize for their needs. They are high school teachers and each year they several requests from students for college letters of recommendations. When they do, they have students fill out a questionnaire evaluation form.
The form requires certain answers to questions to even be eligible to receive a recommendation i.e. they must answer "No" to if they have ever cheated or had an unexcused absence. It also asks students to share their feedback around experiences they had in this teacher's class. The answers provide useful information to include in the recommendation. You may also want to ask students to complete a strength's profile from Thrively which will provide additional useful insights for a recommendation.
Here is a screenshot of the self evaluation and you can see the whole thing here.
For recommendations for professional recommendations, you can change the eligibility and feedback questions to be appropriate for that audience. For example an eligibility questions such as: "Have we ever worked on a professional project together?" I do not write recommendations for those who I have not worked with in an official capacity, so that would be a disqualifying question. A feedback question might be something like "Share what we have worked on together and why you felt it to be a memorable experience." For career recommendations, instead of using a tool like Thrively use one geared toward careers such as Myers Briggs.
What do you think? What is your process for drafting recommendation letters? Do you ask for self-evaluation questions? Are there ideas here you feel would be helpful? Aniy other useful strategies?